Wild Card Book Review

Wild Card Book Review | Elsie Silver’s Chestnut Springs Romance

Author: Elsie Silver
Genres: Contemporary Romance, Small-Town Romance, Cowboy Romance
Publication Date: 2022
Series: Chestnut Springs (Book 1)

Star Rating: ★★★★☆ (4.5/5)

Overview

Wild Card launches Elsie Silver’s Chestnut Springs series, a set of interconnected cowboy romances that have built a passionate readership. This wild card book review looks at how Silver blends heartfelt romance with small-town charm and family tension to create an addictive series starter.

Spoiler-Free Summary

The story follows Vaughn Harding, a professional hockey player sidelined by injury, who returns to his family’s ranch in Chestnut Springs. There, he reconnects with Billie, his childhood best friend and the woman he left behind. As their relationship rekindles, they face both unresolved heartbreak and the complications of family dynamics in a small town.

Writing Style & Craft

Silver’s prose is sharp, emotional, and laced with humor. She balances swoon-worthy romance with raw vulnerability, never shying away from difficult conversations about abandonment, forgiveness, and rebuilding trust. The dialogue feels natural, and her pacing keeps the story moving without sacrificing emotional depth.

Characters & Setting

• Vaughn Harding: A wounded athlete seeking redemption and belonging.
• Billie: Independent, strong-willed, yet still carrying scars from past heartbreak.
• The Harding Family: Complex, loving, but often messy — a realistic portrayal of ranch life.
• Chestnut Springs: The quintessential small-town setting, blending rustic beauty with community drama.

Themes

• Second Chances: Exploring whether love can be rebuilt after betrayal.
• Family & Forgiveness: Navigating the weight of expectation and the bonds of loyalty.
• Identity & Healing: What it means to rediscover oneself after loss and failure.

Strengths & Weaknesses

Strengths: compelling character arcs, emotional depth, steamy romance, authentic small-town atmosphere.
Weaknesses: tropes may feel familiar to seasoned romance readers; pacing slows slightly in midsections focused on family backstory.

Verdict

Wild Card is a heartfelt, emotionally charged romance that sets the tone for the Chestnut Springs series. With its blend of small-town heart and second-chance passion, Elsie Silver delivers a story that is equal parts tender and unforgettable. Final Rating: ★★★★☆ (4.5/5)

Further Reading

For more on Wild Card, see reviews on Goodreads, Barnes & Noble, and Kirkus Reviews.

Related Reviews

If you enjoyed this, explore The Ballad of Falling Dragons, The Primal of Blood and Bone, and Katabasis. Keep your romance and fantasy reads organized with our Reading Tracker.