The Impossible Fortune Book Review

The Impossible Fortune Book Review | Thursday Murder Club Mystery

Author: Richard Osman
Genres: Cozy Mystery, Contemporary Fiction, Crime Fiction
Series: The Thursday Murder Club #5
Publication Date: September 30, 2025

Star Rating: ★★★★☆ (4/5)

Overview

The Impossible Fortune brings the Thursday Murder Club back to life with a blend of warmth, wit, and suspense. This installment balances a high-stakes mystery with tender explorations of grief, aging, and chosen family. This the impossible fortune book review offers a spoiler-free look at what makes this cozy mystery so compelling.

Spoiler-Free Summary

The story kicks off at a wedding, where Joyce’s daughter, Joanna, is getting married. Instead of celebration, a guest—Nick, the best man—confides his fear for his life before vanishing entirely. With whispers of crypto codes, uneasy exes, and missing keys tied to a hidden fortune, the Thursday Murder Club is pulled into one of their most cunning puzzles yet.

Writing Style & Craft

Osman’s signature charm shines through: clever dialogue, cozy humor, and heartfelt moments rooted in genuine emotion. He uses forensic linguistics, witty observations, and subtle cultural critiques — from Bitcoin confusion to eccentric crypto conspiracies — all while anchoring the tale in human connection.

Characters & Setting

• Elizabeth, Joyce, Ibrahim & Ron: The core quartet returns with humor, grief, and insightful wisdom. Elizabeth’s arc, in particular, shows a tender journey out of mourning.
• New Faces: Nick, Joanna’s husband Paul, and young characters like Kendrick add fresh energy and emotional depth.
• The setting—Coopers Chase and the wedding venue—remains a comforting backdrop where friendships and eccentric sleuthing feel natural and inviting.

Themes

• Grief & Renewal: Healing after loss, especially through connection and shared experiences.
• Friendship & Aging: A celebration of companionship in later life, marked by humor and mutual care.
• Technology & Mystery: Modern intrigue (like crypto codes) grounded by quirky characters who bring levity and heart.

Strengths & Weaknesses

Strengths: heartful character development, clever plot with tech intrigue, and genuine humor.
Weaknesses: Some readers found the mystery more familiar or predictable. The emotional tone is lighter than previous installments.

Verdict

The Impossible Fortune adds another warm layer to Osman’s treasured series. While the mystery might be softer, the characters remain the true draw. Loyal readers will cherish seeing their favorites evolve, while new fans will find comfort, humor, and gentle intrigue in every page. Final Rating: ★★★★☆ (4/5)

Further Reading

If you’re intrigued, check out reviews and details at Kirkus Reviews, Star Tribune, and Goodreads.

Related Reviews

Fans of cosy mysteries will enjoy our posts on Culpability, Wreck: A Novel, and elder-led mysteries like Olive Kitteridge. Track your mysteries and all your reads using our Reading Tracker.